You know this team, and the numbers say you own the matchup when you execute. Six games against Cleveland this season — 137 pitches, 35 batters, 8 strikeouts — and the ledger is binary: 13 of your 17 whiffs came in your two bands (heater above the zone, spin below it), while 6 of 7 fastball hits they managed came from the one place the ball should never be: the 2–3 ft middle band. Rocchio's homer sat at 2.8. Both Hoskins singles sat at 2.2 and 2.4. Same shapes every time — the only variable was height. And you just showed in Houston (5 K in Game 1) that the October version of you is the slider-forward one they've barely seen.
Who they are vs RHP
- CONTACT FIRST Kwan whiffs 6.7%, DeLauter 13%, Ramírez 16.5% — strikeouts must be chosen carefully.
- ZONE VELO They punish 97+ in the zone: Hoskins .513, Kwan .443, Bazzana .441, Ramírez .388.
- BUT THEY CHASE Martínez 43%, Halpin 39%, Watson 37%, Schneemann 35%, Bailey 33% — and the ladder works: Watson 60%, Schneemann 51%, Halpin 50%, Manzardo 47% whiff on elevated four-seams.
The series rule
- THE HEATER NEVER LIVES IN THE ZONE. Above the letters it's a weapon (47% whiff). In the band, this team hits it harder than anyone you've faced — and your own six games against them prove it.
- THE SLIDER IS FRESH They've seen it 20 times all year (15% of your pitches to them) — and it's your best whiff pitch now (36.4%).
- See History for the full book on what they've seen.
Best of five. Games 1–2 at Progressive Field, 3–4 at Rate Field, 5 back in Cleveland. They're off the bye (rested, but cold); you've already pitched a playoff game. Hoskins is working back from a back injury — his card stays warm in case he's activated. Playoff roster wasn't final at build time; lock the posted lineup each night.
The book — what Cleveland has seen from you in 2026
Six meetings: 137 pitches · 35 PA · 8 K · 6 BB · 9 hits. This is the familiarity series — they have a book on you, and you have receipts on them.
What you've shown them
A third of everything they've seen is the curve — the heater-up/curve-down pattern is the book they'll bring into Game 1. The slider is the page they don't have: 20 pitches all season, most of them Sept 15 — the night it struck out Bazzana and retired Ramírez.
Every miss you got — where it lived
13 of 17 whiffs came in the two bands: four-seams at 3.0–4.1 ft (Genao at 4.1, Watson and Halpin at 3.8, Rocchio at 3.2) and curves buried at 0.2–1.3 ft (Halpin at 0.2, Schneemann at 0.7, Rocchio at 0.8, Bailey twice). The Sept 15 sliders got Bazzana twice more. Your bands work on this team — October doesn't change that.
Every ball that hurt — same address
6 of 7 fastball hits came from the 2–3 ft band: Rocchio's homer on a four-seam at 2.8, Hoskins singles at 2.4 and 2.2, Genao at 2.4, Lowe at 2.9, plus Rocchio's double on a sinker that caught 3.4. Nothing they hit was a located pitch. The mistake band is the whole threat.
The receipts that matter
JUL 2Rocchio HR — four-seam 99 at 2.8 ft. Two weeks earlier you struck him out on a curve at 0.8. Same hitter, two heights, two outcomes.
JUN 22–JUL 2Kwan: 3 PA, 2 walks, zero whiffs. Nibbling him is how he beats you — he won't chase and he won't miss. Spin in the zone, let him hit it on the ground.
JUN–SEPHoskins: 5 swings, 0 whiffs, singles on heaters at 2.2 and 2.4. Both hits were band mistakes, not good swings on good pitches.
SEP 15The slider arrives — Bazzana swings through two and strikes out; Ramírez rolls one over at 1.7 ft. The freshest look you have, shown on the most recent night they saw you.
SEP 29 · WC G1The October version — 54 pitches vs Houston: 5 K, 1 BB, 2 H, and the slider thrown as often as the heater (17 each). The pattern Cleveland scouted all summer isn't the one that shows up Saturday.
Guardians vs RHP — full series pool, tap a hitter
Elite
High
Med
Low
Ordered by season damage vs RHP · LIM = thin sample
Your arsenal — full-season shapes, October-tested
FF
Four-Seam
THE LADDER
43.7% used
98 with 16.7" of carry — 47% whiff above 3.2 ft, and Cleveland's chasers whiff 47–60% up there. In the zone band this team hits it (.388–.513 vs 97+ for their best bats): above the letters or edges, never middle
2338 rpm · 7.1 ft extension · Wild Card G1: velo held (FF 97.5, SI 99.0) across 54 October pitches
CU
Curveball
THE PIT
27.1% used
61% whiff below 1.6 ft — every buried curve vs Cleveland this year got the swing-and-miss. One warning: Bazzana (.556 vs curves league-wide) gets the slider instead
2517 rpm · 7.1 ft extension · Wild Card G1: velo held (FF 97.5, SI 99.0) across 54 October pitches
SL
Slider
THE FRESH PAGE
16.6% used
career-best 36.4% whiff and the page Cleveland doesn't have — 20 shown all season. Sept 15 proof: two Bazzana whiffs and a strikeout. In the Wild Card you threw it as often as the heater — keep that
2618 rpm · 7.1 ft extension · Wild Card G1: velo held (FF 97.5, SI 99.0) across 54 October pitches
SI
Sinker
GROUNDER
12.3% used
99 with run — the ground-ball pitch to the contact bats; a weak roll-over from Kwan or DeLauter is a win
2305 rpm · 7.1 ft extension · Wild Card G1: velo held (FF 97.5, SI 99.0) across 54 October pitches
▦ The familiarity series — and why it favors you
They've seen you six times, and what their book says is: heater up, curve to follow. What it can't say yet is the slider — your best whiff pitch now, shown to them 20 times all year — or the Wild Card version of you that threw it as often as the heater. Their lineup is lefty-heavy contact that punishes zone velo and chases below it. So the plan is almost insultingly simple: the heater never lives in the band, the spin never stops, and the slider is the surprise you spend one hitter at a time.
The ladder — pick your spots
Watson (60%), Schneemann (51%), Halpin (50%), Manzardo (47%), Bailey (46%) whiff huge on elevated four-seams. But this is a spot weapon here, not the default: Kwan (8%), Ramírez (28%), Bazzana (35%) mostly don't miss up there. Check the card, then climb.
The pit — the chase crew
Martínez (43%), Halpin (39%), Watson (37%), Schneemann (35%), Bailey (33%), Rocchio (33%) all expand down. Two strikes: curve at the shoetops — every buried curve vs this team this year was swung through. Exception: Bazzana, who hits curves (.556) — he gets the slider.
The zone-velo rule
Hoskins .513, Kwan .443, Bazzana .441, Ramírez .388 vs 97+ — and your own six games show it (every hit they got: fastball, 2–3 ft). The heater gets strikes on the edges and whiffs above. It does not get challenged with in this series. Ever.
Your options — throw this / not that
Five games, one surprise — budget it
A best-of-five against a division rival means every look compounds. Game 1: they're sitting on the summer book (heater up, curve down) — let them have it, executed. The slider shows up when it ends at-bats, not as a get-me-over, so by Games 4–5 it's still a fresh answer. If the ladder gets taken (this team doesn't chase up like Houston did), the pit is the fallback — their chase lives below the zone, not above it.
SliderFEATURE · THE FRESH PAGE
THROWCareer-best 36.4% whiff, and Cleveland has seen 20 all season. It's the answer to their two best righty-killers: Bazzana (.214, 36% whiff vs sliders — struck out on it Sept 15) and Ramírez (.237 — rolled it over at 1.7 ft that same night). Back-foot to the lefty stack: Schneemann whiffs 40% against it at .130.
NOT THATDon't spend it early in counts or show it twice in a row — it's the series' one surprise, and DeLauter (.370) and Rocchio (.379) cover it. Check the card first.
Four-SeamFEATURE · ABOVE OR EDGES ONLY
THROW47% whiff above 3.2 ft — and your Cleveland whiffs all came 3.0–4.1 ft (Genao at 4.1 was the prettiest pitch you threw them all year). Edges for called strikes, above the letters to finish the ladder crew.
NOT THATNever, ever the 2–3 ft band: Rocchio's homer (2.8), both Hoskins singles (2.2, 2.4), Lowe (2.9) — every fastball Cleveland has hit off you lived there, and their best bats run .388–.513 against zone velo. This is the one rule of the series.
CurveballTHE PIT · KNOW THE EXCEPTIONS
THROW61% whiff below 1.6 ft, and a perfect record vs Cleveland when buried: Rocchio (0.8), Halpin (0.2), Schneemann (0.7), Bailey (0.9, 1.3) all swung through it. Two strikes on the chase crew, and a free first-pitch strike to the takers.
NOT THATNot to Bazzana (.556 vs curves league-wide — your June strikeouts of him came before the league learned this, don't re-test it) and not to Martínez (.503). They've also seen 45 of these — a hung curve is the pitch they're most prepared for.
SinkerGROUNDER · THE KWAN PITCH
THROW99 with run for the contact bats you shouldn't chase strikeouts against — Kwan, DeLauter, Genao. A rolled-over single-saver with traffic on, and the double-play ball.
NOT THATDon't let it drift to 2–3 ft either — Rocchio doubled on one at 3.4, and Kwan hits zone velo (.443). Down and in, or not at all.